The Illinois Supreme Court just unanimously ruled the Illinois eavesdropping law unconstitutional. The law made it illegal to record any person, whether in public or private, unless they consented. Typically, the law was applied against citizens recording governmental officials; however, the issue of eavesdropping rears its head in divorce cases where frequently spouses investigate and record each other.Annabel Melongo, incarcerated for almost 2 years, had recorded several phone calls with a court reporter about how to correct a hearing transcript. The Cook County States Attorney charged her with six counts of eavesdropping. What kept her in jail until trial was the $500,000 bond she could not afford. There was a hung jury after the trial and the States Attorney was going to try her again; Melongo filed her own motion to dismiss and the trial judge dismissed criminal charges against her. The States Attorney appealed directly to the Illinois Supreme Court which found the law unconstitutional.Until the Illinois legislature approves a new eavesdropping statute there is no prohibition on eavesdropping in Illinois except as limited by federal law which only requires one party to a recording to authorize it. The now unconstitutional Illinois law required that both parties to the recording to so authorize.
Mar 24, 2014
Eavesdropping in Illinois No Longer a Crime? That is Correct, For the Time Being.
News and Insights
Feb 12, 2025
If Tax Accounting is Black and White, Family Law Exists in Every Shade of Grey
Any family law attorney involved in any financially sophisticated divorce case needs to ...
Jan 27, 2025
Congratulations to our 26 Attorneys Recognized by Super Lawyers in 2025!
Congratulations to all of the Schiller, DuCanto & Fleck attorneys recognized as 2025 ...
Dec 10, 2024
The Role of Fault in Modern Divorce
In this episode of Until Death Do Us Pod, Senior Partner Jay Dahlin sits down with ...